Showing posts with label HR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label HR. Show all posts

Friday, December 7, 2012

HR . . . A Friend in Need OR A Friend Indeed ! ?


Where employees see HR personnel as a devil’s advocate (devil refers to management here), and management presumes HR to serve them as an advisory, HR is always expected to play with this double – edged sword effectively. And here comes the most difficult role of walking along the tight rope of managing expectations. This funambulism does not come easy to all, and needs to be acquired/developed. However amidst all this, HR feels trapped in a dilemma whether to be sociable with the employees, or to always keep the ‘professional’ approach in dealing with the staff.

There are 2 perspectives to this theory: (a) The HR Angle (b) The Employee Angle. We shall look at both from the HR point of view here.

Let’s first take the HR personnel’s angle. First and foremost argument I would like to make here is that “HR Personnel are people too.” They too are individuals who seek a confidante amongst people with whom they spend 8-9 hours in a day. HR people too are individuals who walk in with emotions much alike any other employee.
But again, they have a job to do, of ensuring discipline and managing conflicting-interest situations. They have no option but to fear such predicament, because a true HR professional should not be affected by personal biases and prejudices. Better safe than sorry! You undertake a risk of being misquoted, as what you have said or done in personal capacity or as a joke might be perceived as an act by an “HR” of the organisation.

However, it is also necessary to keep yourself approachable, since employees need to feel free to talk about their issues to the HR. Most of the times, what they just require is a good listener. Also, it helps HR understand the culture and systems prevalent in the organisation. It thus becomes imperative for an HR professional to be able to clearly distinguish between personal and professional effects in a relationship. If one cannot do so, he/she must refrain from friendships on a personal level with the colleagues. It is essential to understand that organisational commitments have precedence over personal bias.

Looking at this from an Employee’s Perspective, where some people fear coming in close quarters with HR, some employees purposefully connect with you. Very starkly, we can see employees being very conscious of what they say/do when HR is around. You find them abruptly changing the topic of conversations, or hush when HR unexpectedly appears in the scene; may be because they feel that HR is always judgemental.
Often, ‘being friends’ with the HR is seen as an option by the employees, not by choice but by compulsion. They do take extra efforts to ‘update’ / ‘inform’ HR occasionally about their achievements, especially when it’s something beyond the demands of their role. Well, some employees see to it that they make the so-called ‘true’ friendships with HR, with the sole anticipation of extracting confidential information that HR is expected to have. These are the testing times for HR. For a mature HR professional, difficult here is not that he/she needs to choose the organisation over friendship; but to not choose friendship over job commitments. It requires strong will, risk-bearing ability and clear professional & personal goals, making emotional stress a part of routine.

All said and done, it is absolutely indispensable for HR to be friendly with the employees. Being social with colleagues outside office might be a riskier option, nonetheless they always need to be aware that every move they make or every word they say, must be well-thought upon to measure the consequences. Performing a balancing act during the working hours also becomes elemental. While keeping the ‘human element’ in our profession alive, we sometimes need to forget that we too are human beings with emotional needs, we too have issues that we need to share with ‘friends’, we too need to enjoy and spend some casual moments with colleagues without calculating costs and risks that we might have to bear. May be we need to change the very definition of “FRIENDSHIP” that otherwise applies to us in the outside world. . .

- VAISHALI PARGAONKAR

Thursday, October 25, 2012

RESUME BLUNDERS! (Part - II)


         In accordance with my promise that I will continue to collect more artefacts (pls refer my earlier blog @ http://vaishalipargaonkar.blogspot.in/2012/04/resume-blunders.htmlONLY FOR THE SAKE OF HUMOUR! ... here is the 2nd set of Resume Blunders for you.

          Hope you have a hearty laugh. Have cited my comments (VP) for each …. Enjoy!

1) Objective: 

My first intention is to use my knowledge to understand my work. As a result of this my work will become easier and I will understand the strength of my knowledge. It may be beneficial for all and I would get the fruitful results.

VP: A flowchart representation of intentions and abilities ... 


2) Summary : 

I myself  xxxx  have qualified CA Exam. with in three years both groups in one sitting. 

VP:  What an achievement to boast of! I'm sure my CA friends do comprehend this.


3) Candidate Text Resume : I don\'t wish to disclose now.

VP: Resume of a secret agent ... I guess!


4) Others:   

I am very passionate about my physical and mental fitness. I do Gym every morning for workout of 60 minutes and also listen to classical music for urban stress busting.

VP: Now this can really get me a good job .....  hmmm! Any takers?


5)  I MR xxxxx HAVING xx YRS EXPERIANCE IN CIVIL WORKS WOULD LIKE TO APPLY FOR THE ABOVE SAID POST IF GIVEN CHANCE TO WORK IN YOUR ESTEEMEED ORGANISATION WILL WORK WITH FULL LOYALTY TOWARDS THE ORGANISATION ALL GIVEN INFORMATION ARE TRUE MY KNOWLEDGE FOR YOUR KIND APPROVAL FOR THE SAME

VP: Breathless! This gentleman does not believe in punctuation. 


6) Current Designation: Additional General Manager – Projects

VP: 'Additional' ... ??!!  I would never want to be an 'additional' whoever. 


7) MORE IMPORTANT THAN ANYTHING ELSE YOU READ IN THIS RESUME IS THE FACT THAT I CAN GET THINGS DONE. I CAN MAKE THINGS HAPPEN.

VP: Resume of Rajnikant ... yenna rascala !!


8) Career objective : 

With my knowledge and good communication skill I assume my self in a position in an organization where I can contribute towards the development of organization as well as hones in all my assignment. 

VP: No comments... just laugh :)


9)  OBJECTIVE :  

TO JOIN A HOTEL AND GROW  WITH IT.

VP: Please apply at infancy stage of your life!



10) OBJECTIVE 

To provide the best service wherein being continuously, as a part of a team that dynamically works towards growth of the organization and to achieve excellence there of.

VP: Yes... finally we have a Shakespeare in the making..!



And like always... I have saved the best for the last .... 

11) I have been able to consummate advanced techniques with self initiative ability to work effectively to lead the team effort to its achievements.

VP: Yeah ...  I know its dirty thinking... hahaha!


              Hope you guys enjoyed reading this. And as promised, I will keep up the good work of collecting such artifacts. If you have come across any creative work, please feel free to share …. 

ONLY FOR THE SAKE OF HUMOUR! 

                Hey and do not forget to mention which one you liked the best!



- VAISHALI PARGAONKAR


Monday, April 23, 2012

RESUME BLUNDERS! (Part - I)


Resumes flow in and out of my hands characteristically, being in the HR profession. I come across some innocent, sincere lines mentioned by candidates many a times, which convey a different meaning altogether than what is intended.

Here are a few such examples. Have inserted my comments (VP) for each…. Enjoy!

Disclaimer:  Please note that this article is posted Just for Fun, and has no intention to hurt, ridicule or insult any person in particular whatsoever.

  1. Please see last Left for Educational Summary
VP: Seems like some direction for a Map!


  1. Designation: sales exicativew
VP: Tried real hard to get it right!


  1. Job Profile:-
Independently looking after Vice President of project ………
VP: May be he is applying for a nurse’s job!


  1. ACHIVMENTS successfully construcated the residentian, commercial.molles. scheme "shravan apparment from shihagad road & vagholi from row housses & raje contruction,cumarsial bilding(8 floor)&ambegone
VP: Read the sentence without taking a breath! Hoooosssshhh!   


  1. I possess the ability to relate a wide range of people and capable of achieving personal goals and objectives performing with my professional carrier till date.
VP: Achieving personal goals with ‘professional carrier’? …. Hmmm!


  1. Having good respect in Organization with family status.
VP: I still dint get this! If anyone of you gets it, please post a comment to explain!

  1. OTHER SKILLS :                  INDIAN DRIVING LICESES.
VP: Obtaining an ‘Indian’ driving licence…. Does it require any skill? I doubt if it even requires driving skills for that matter.


  1. Saved company money by taking on several job responsibilities.
VP: Now that’s a real achievement!


  1. Marital Status-Married
Hobbies-Body Building


VP: hahahahaha! No comments!


  1. Note-Now I’am free for my new Corse I.T.I Serveior Exmanation as a Temperary leave from- -company.
              VP: Thanks for the info. I shall remember!

11.    Industry Type             : Real Estate
Product                       : Multi Storage Apartments’.
VP: Storage for humans!

  1. HOBBIES           : - TOURRING AT OUT SIDE.
VP: Does anyone have a hobby of Tourring at In Side too?


13.   Willingness to learn, keep passions & cool in nature, believes in hardworking as well as smart work.

VP: Keeping passions is a valuable trait really!


  1. PROJECT WARK DONE:- Panting work & Advantage & Disadvantage of panting
VP: Hahahahaha! You corrupt minds. He is talking about ‘Painting’! How a missing ‘i’ can bring laughter to our innocent souls!

  1. SEMINAR:- All type of vibrater use in construction
VP: Again, No comments! What are you thinking?

  1. EXTRA CURRICULAR:- Social Work
Hospitality of pilgrims every year

VP: I always thought extracurricular meant sports, reading, dancing, cooking etc.!

  1. JOB RESPOUNCEBILITY:
VP: Quite a pouncing one that is!


  1. About Myself
I AM WORKERS AND SINCERE IN MAY JOB HAVING GOOD QUALITIES OF ESTABLISHING AND MAINTAINING RELATIONSHIP WITH PEOPLE HONESTY INTEGRITY FAITHFULLNESS AND JOYALLY ARE MY STRENGTHS I ALWAYS ENJOY TO ACCEPT NEW CHALLENGES IN LIFE.

VP: In Marathi they say 'Bhavana pohochlya', means 'got the point'.


19.   Summary:Plz dont look after my Profil. I m Fresher in this field.I m office Admin in XXXX  pvt ltd. From 2years

VP: No one dares to see his profile, got it!?


  1. CAREER OBJECTIVE
To, pull the best from within to rice to the occasion, only to leave the marks where I work.

VP: Seems like an application for a farmer!


  1. STRENGTH:
Able to work for longer period without any mental and physical strain.

VP: Superman!


Now, these 2 have been received as emails:
22.  Respected Mam,               
        As per your contacts to me, you have called me for interview today. But, today at 1:30 pm. our companie's C.M.D are coming our site for visiting propram. So, there some meetings are achived among us. So, I'm sorry for this situation!  I will come soon with my c.v. in office for iterview!                  Thanking you!               
        'GOOD DAY'!!

VP: Though, I truly appreciate that he bothered to inform in advance!


  1.  feb-11 & mar-11 not open excel sheet pls this convert be excel-2003. apr-11 to jun-11 salary sheet open only two month not open salary sheet.pls send repeat
VP: My job is at stake! I wonder what I’m supposed to do here!


Hope you guys enjoyed reading this. I will keep up the good work of collecting such artifacts. If you have come across any creative work, please feel free to share …. 

ONLY FOR THE SAKE OF HUMOUR! J

Hey and do not forget to mention which one you liked the best!


P.S.: Fun continued... blog posted on Thursday, October 25, 2012


- VAISHALI PARGAONKAR

More Fun @ 1)  Funny Stupid things people write in a resume
                       2)  150 Funniest Resume Mistakes, Bloopers and Blunders Ever

4 comments:

  1. LOL...yeh sab padh ke mujhe apne common friend ki yaad aayi..he is still not in contact with me..
    ReplyDelete
  2. LOL... which version of excel does u use ....
    ReplyDelete
  3. My personal favourites:
    1) Marital Status-Married
    Hobbies-Body Building

    2)PROJECT WARK DONE:- Panting work & Advantage & Disadvantage of panting

    3)feb-11 & mar-11 not open excel sheet pls this convert be excel-2003. apr-11 to jun-11 salary sheet open only two month not open salary sheet.pls send repeat
    ReplyDelete

    Replies


    1. TOURRING AT OUT SIDE. hahahha.... lets go to toor at in side ulsoh...
      Delete


Friday, March 9, 2012

Performance Appraisal of the Performance Appraisal System


         March end is nearing and its time for Appraisals. All eyes are focussed on the one most important thing ‘Appraisals’ and ‘Increments’. To an HR professional, these two words have distinguished definitions. But, to a layman Appraisals mean Increments and Increments mean Appraisals.

For all those who still think they mean the same, here’s the dictionary meaning for both:

  • Appraisal - an assessment or estimation of the worth, value, or quality of a person or thing

  • Increment - The process of increasing in number, size, quantity, or extent.

These two terms are related, but not the same. However, in a typically traditionally managed, family owned business, there may be not be much of a practical difference between the two, but in larger organisations Appraisals and Increments have a larger system in place called the Performance Management System.


          There is much ado about effective Performance Management Systems (PMS) and a lot many theories have been conceptualised for building a robust PMS. The most popular amongst these are the 360 degrees, 180 degrees, Management by Objectives (MBO), Ratings Scale methods.


Organisations invest a great deal of money, time and efforts in formulating a PMS system that suits their organisational needs, culture and business plans. The effectiveness of any PMS depends on many factors from Goal Setting Process to the Evaluation Methodology and the Feedback Mechanism, but the major factor that influences the success of an organisation’s PMS is the ‘buy-in’ from the top management.

When you talk of Appraisals, employees imagine a herculean task coming forward i.e. of filling up pages and booklets of information. Amidst targets and deadlines, employees struggle to manage recollecting and providing information not only about their own performance, but also for their colleagues as in the 360 degree approach. What do companies do with all this download of information? Are the companies effectively utilising the data generated for the benefit of the employees and the organisation? Do companies review the Performance Appraisal Systems viz-a-viz the results it generates?


         In a webinar on "Designing an Effective Performance Management System" hosted by SHRM India; the speaker Aniruddha Limaye, an Independent Consultant, pointed out indicators that we need to be sniffing for, to understand when to start instituting a new PMS or get rid of the existing one altogether. According to his theory, the key indicators that we need to look at are:

Employee related issuesunfavourable feedback from employees on PMS, increase in employee attrition linked to appraisal cycle

Performance related issueslow ownership by line managers that requires tremendous follow up by HR, lack of team work / turf mentality, organisation struggling to achieve goals, difficulty in implementing any new decisions /changes / initiatives


         In most companies, Performance Assessment becomes just an HR or Admin process. HR does play a role in setting up of the process, coordinating the execution, and for normalisation. But Forced Ranking, Bell Curve Method, Jack Welch’s 20-70-10 principle come into picture as regularisation methods, which might prove to be de-motivating for many employees. “By implementing a forced ranking procedure, organizations guarantee that managers will differentiate talent”, says Dick Grote in his book ‘Forced Ranking: Making Performance Management Work’. Does forced Ranking mean appraisal of the manager’s ability to appraise his subordinates?

If PMS does not have the status of a ‘Business Process’ the organisation should think of scrapping it rather than redesigning it. PMS is not an HR process, but should come as a buy-in from the top management. Without an objective Goal-Setting process and a strong & positive Feedback Mechanism, performance cannot be reinforced. Hence, if an organisation’s PMS lacks these two important requisites, it is always advisable to scrap it rather than having a negative impact on employee’s expectations from the system.

        As quoted by Limaye, “You need to catch someone doing something right and then reinforce it!”

       When in spite of incessant initiatives of reviving the Appraisal System, there is still demand / need for change, performance appraisal systems could be eliminated with no harm done. No Performance Assessment System will work until the organisation is completely ready for the change it desires to bring in with the system.

          All in all, performance review is a daily activity, and not an annual ritual led by the HR delegates.

- VAISHALI PARGAONKAR




Friday, August 19, 2011

Corporate India v / s India Against Corruption

Do you think Corporate India should take a step forward to fight against corruption and declare a Days Off to enable the employees to support the movement?  This question was posed by an HR Forum on Facebook, which earned 108 likes and 61 comments from HR and non-HR professionals.

The same morning, I had similar questions in mind as to whether corporate should participate in this revolutionary stance taken by our iconic leader Anna Hazare. I have been following this story since Anna Hazare’s fast a few months ago, when I learnt about what Jan Lokpal Bill is all about. Keeping in mind what the bill will do to our warped system, and that activists like Kiran Bedi, Arun Kejriwal and the rest are supporting Anna, I too started having faith in this movement. Moreover Anna’s aura gives feel-good vibes as contrast to Baba Ramdev who (supposedly) fasted for the same cause.

Coming back to the question, of what role can Corporates play & whether this should be taken up as an Act of CSR.; being an HR professional, my arguments run from philosophy to policy. Gathering from what my FB friends who commented on the question, majority of the 61 people who spared time to pen down a word or two, have agreed with a ‘BIG YES’ and feel that Corporates should declare atleast 1 day off so that employees can support this anti-corruption movement. Well, I too am stung with these pests infecting all of India with scams, and hence primarily I too concur with Anna Hazares movement.

I strongly believe that the philosophy of management here is of utmost importance. Anna says that everyone needs to sacrifice their bit...only then we can bring an end to corruption. But people always think that the rest are anyways sacrificing... so what difference does it make if I don’t. This attitude itself has led us to this day, when we are seeing another ‘Freedom Struggle’ after independence today.

Not many companies will come forward and declare even 1 day off and incur loss in business due to same. Forget at least supporting the cause, if not actually bringing an end to corruption (Not to forget most of our big corporate leaders have played some or the other role in giving oil to fire). In the recent past, corporates had given days off for Semi-Final and Final matches of the 2011 World Cup. I don’t know whether I should say that it’s a shame why corporates are not coming forward today when India really needs its people.

On the other hand, I will not only blame the corporates for not showing any interest. Even for employees (you and me), will only updating Facebook and Twitter statuses and joining online forums actually help? Yes, it will definitely spread the awareness, but even if we assume that corporates declare a day off, how many people will actually get down on the roads and join the rally? Employees can take leaves for watching World Cup matches, but given a day to join the protest, are people really interested? And so instead people in the HR forum suggested that organizations can dedicate 30 minutes of the entire day regularly for the cause, a common meet of all employees across the country can be called for and such. One friend even suggested ‘pens and tools down’ instead of a holiday. As pointed by a colleague from the forum, who knows a days off means good time at a Cinema hall for somebody.

Well, after a debate like this… yes it is duty of the corporates to pay attention to such issues and contribute in every small way they can. Only providing donations and setting up NGO’s is not enough, corporates must also pay heed to internal corruption issues and setting up a system that will prevent corruption in the first place rather than inspecting and punishing for the same. However, why wait for your company to come forward? We have examples of students and office-goers who have taken a week’s off and are participating in the movement. So why wait until someone else starts? Why not just go ahead and let others follow? We can participate and still keep the business moving. Afterall, every corporate is part of Indian economy, and we must keep the spirit going….

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Good Performance v/s Bad Behaviour

"Congrats! Mr. A, you have been promoted to a Manager!"

Mr. A has 12 years of work experience and is known as a devoted and hard working individual. A performer at his work, Mr. A has many achievements to his credit and has progressed from an execution role to a managerial role.

Performing as an individual is very different than performing in a team. And especially when you are leading & managing a team, a person requires different set of skills and competencies. A person may be good at executing activities on his own, but getting work done from people might not come so easy.

Going back to Mr. A, he has been awarded as the "Best Performer of the Year", has been appreciated enough in his appraisals and is the apple of the eye of the top management. Mr. A follows certain rules of a manager that most at his level do. He believes in empowering his team, but at the same time follows a ‘school-teacher with a stick in hand’ approach. His leadership style can be categorized as directive and traditional.

So are his subordinates convinced with his style of management?

Mr. A is resolute on getting results from his team. Hence smallest of errors made by the subordinate become a big issue to be dealt with. He wants his team to be as perfect in work as he is. After all, his performance will not shine if the subordinates don't obtain the desired results. Being impulsive and very straight forward, like Mr. A appreciates good work of his subordinates promptly, he also sometimes loses his cool over his subordinates mistakes and yells at them without realizing that everybody else is also listening. Instead of taking the latter to a secluded place for counseling, he loses patience and unintentionaly creates an embarrassing situation for the subordinate. And this does not end in a minute or a two, but becomes a 10-15 minute ordeal for the subordinate.

Mr. A sometimes doesn’t even care to make sure whether the error is actually done, and passes a judgmental statement at the subordinate, who ends up justifying for an offence never committed. He also gets a bit personal, so much so, that Mr. A actually forgets the mistake in question and sounds like a spouse taunting the other for all the flaws he has figured out in his entire lifetime.

Well, the result of the same turns out to be expected -- subordinates body language in front of other colleagues changes for the rest of the day, he/she feels highly embarrassed and de-motivated, sometimes even sheds a tear or a two when the going gets tough. And often you see this subordinate smiling his way to glory, relaxed and all enthusiastic when Mr. A is not around. He seems to be more productive when the bullying boss is not in vicinity.

Now let’s see what is Mr. A's behaviour with the rest of the colleagues. Mr. A shares a good rapport with his colleagues being extrovert by nature, and is respected by all for his work, helpful and friendly nature. However, he is famous for being cynical and sarcastic and spreads this kind of culture amongst all. After all, you give back what you get, especially when it is comments that you do not enjoy listening to. Mr. A sounds tyrannical at times, is rude and tries to shield his sarcasm with humour, but obviously does not succeed at all times. The outcome of his nasty, teasing and hurtful jokes results in employees hitting on each other for every small thing. Many instances have ended up in conflicting situations when some employee on that day chooses to not ignore the hurtful remarks but take necessary action and revolt against such behavior. The workplace then becomes like a warfront where the ammunition most used are devastating words.

So, I keep wondering about this Good Performance v/s Bad Behaviour. Definitely, Mr. A is a bully at the workplace, but he also is a good performer. Active bullying is manifested through clear evidences, but passive bullying where the person does not actually seem like a tormenter but acts like a slow poison, is difficult to deal with. You cannot even ignore it and you can’t even complain about it.

So what is the plight of the subordinate???

• The verbal and emotional abuse results in loss of productivity
• Increase in level of absenteeism
• Emotional stress to deal with
• Lack of team-work
• Reduced efficiency and increased errors due to fear

What results in such bullying behavior by the boss?

• Aggression and passion to perform
• Personal nature and temperament
• Impulsiveness / lack of tolerance power
• Newly acquired managerial responsibilities and the resulting pressure to perform
• Lack of communication skills
• Lack of leadership and team handling skills

According to a study by the Employment Law Alliance in 2008, almost half of all employees have been targeted by a bully boss. The study also revealed the following:
• 81 percent of bullies are managers.
• 50 percent of bullies are women and 50 percent are men.
• 84 percent of targets are women.
• 82 percent of targets ultimately lost their job.
• 95 percent of bullying is witnessed.

MY QUESTION:

1. As an HR what should be done to curtail such behavior to protect the victim as well as improve the culture of the organization?

2. If the bullying boss is a performer and contributor, should such behavior (keeping in mind that the boss is not a crude or raging bully, but subtle bully) be ignored? If not, what strategy needs to be used to counsel the boss, such that he does not get demotivated but at the same time takes corrective action for his conduct?

- VAISHALI PARGAONKAR

Sunday, December 26, 2010

Paternity Leave : Daddy Days Off!

It was when 2 female colleagues of mine availed a ‘maternity leave’ I recollected that a few months back I had had a chance to enjoy sweets distributed by a male colleague. He was sharing his happiness for having become a proud father.
As an HR professional I started to wonder if men should be given paternity leave rights just like women enjoy the privilege of availing maternity leave……Yes. Men do not give birth to children (literally), but they do become fathers and apart from what’s fair and unfair to them a logical argument would make more meaning to an HR professional.


Paternity Leave Law in India:
In India, the Central Government endorses the concept of granting paternity leaves to fathers along with maternity leaves to mothers. And it also makes all Central Government employees eligible for paid benefits for availing such leaves.

Rule 551(A) - Paternity Leave – 6th Central Pay Commission-

  •  A male CG servant (including an apprentice) with less than two surviving children may be granted 15 days Paternity Leave during the confinement of his wife for childbirth
  • The Paternity Leave can be availed up to 15 days before or up to six months from the date of delivery of the child.
  • Paternity Leave shall not be debited to the leave account.
  • It shall not be refused under any circumstances.
  • During paternity leave, leave salary equal to last pay drawn is admissible.
Well, the law does say so….but the private sector is not bound by this law and hence need of an argument whether giving fathers time off is essential or is an extra privilege that may not be required.
    On some secondary research about Paternity Leave laws in India and other countries, I realised that the most common need of the hour is to receive both income and job-protected time off after the birth of a child. Here are some arguments that people of different professions from different countries have put forth…..

    Arguments ‘FOR’ granting Paternity Leaves:

    1. In the early stages of parenting, the presence of both mother and father is equally important for the child
    2. As the mother is recuperating from post-partum depression, it becomes difficult for the mother to look after the child alone. With the father around, not only he can offer help with domestic chores, medical care of mother and child, but also give the mother moral or emotional support, and spend quality time with his family. In the first week when the mother and child are at the hospital a lot of running around is required and can be taken care of by the father. Paternity leave becomes very important when there have been complications during childbirth and extra care needs to be taken.
    3. With changing culture in India, and changing family structures where women are also working, most families in cities are nuclear and may also have parents or elders living in another city, state or country. Also today grandparents might also be working and hence, reliance on babysitters, nannies and maids increases. Not to forget, not all households can afford to hire maids / nannies to take care of the child.
    4. Why burden only the mothers? And also, if mothers can get a maternity leave, then in these times of gender-equality why not paternity leaves to the father?
    5. Father-child bond in the early stages of life is very important, and who says that father does not feel the need of spending time with his new born? Even the father wants to witness all the ‘first-time’ doings of his new born.
    6. Like Mum, Like Dad: Fathers should be prepared to do tasks like changing their child’s nappies and feeding food to the newborn
    7. Fathers do end up availing some leaves amortizing on their paid leaves. They have to save on leaves right from the wife gets pregnant so that they can support her after child birth. This can get stressful. And when the employee ends up availing excess leaves, he might even undergo a loss of pay, which at this crucial times of multiplied expenses adds to the stress
    8. Will the male employee be productive at work when his mind and soul would be with his wife and the child, and would he not take leaves often in the first few days after the child birth?
    Arguments ‘AGAINST’ granting Paternity Leaves:
    1. We already have maximum number of public holidays as compared to any other country
    2. Engaging mother and father at the same time for one cause is not justified / necessary
    3. The ‘man’ is not much helpful in pregnancy days. The pains and complications of pregnancy can be shared and solved with the women friends / relatives only.
    4. Women in India generally go and live with their parents during delivery and few months afterwards
    5. By taking 10/15 days leave, the couple increases chances of quarreling instead of helping each other
    6. Men cannot waste time for long or afford any disruption in their career. They must not give priority to emotional feelings over career. Men would not like to put their career on hold, or give it a break
    7. Men around the house during daytime are more of a hindrance. In India still....men are not that domesticised, maybe a decade down the line, things may change
    8. Someone has to work to maintain the cash flow
    9. Women are hardworking and dedicated unlike men. Handling of such responsibilities by men will only come with time. Hence, it is better to increase maternity leaves
    Laws in Other countries:
    ·                                                                                             SWEDEN: A Revolutionary Policy
    Parents are entitled to a total of 480 days paid leave per child, with both mothers and fathers entitled and encouraged to share the leave. The leave can be taken at any time until the child reaches the age of seven. Mothers and fathers are expected to share the 480 days equally.  It is possible for one parent to take up to 420 days of the total leave, but the remaining 60 days are then reserved for the other parent. In addition to the paid leave of 480 days per couple per child, you are entitled to reduce your working time by 25 percent. This, however, is not compensated for by the state.

    Companies in India that grant Paternity Leaves:
    Amongst many, below are a few companies that grant Paternity Leave to employees:

    • NIIT claims to be the first to offer paternity leave from 1995.
    • Employees of Infosys are eligible to avail three continuous working days of paternity leave and this option is available for the birth of the first two children.
    • Omega Healthcare services – 5 days
    • Datacraft India – 3 days
    • Wipro Technologies – 0 days
    • MNC’s in India such as Google, Cisco, Accenture, and Intel, most of which have paternity policies in place. Cisco Systems' India office has the most generous paternity leave of 12 weeks followed by Google India, which offers two weeks. Other multinationals which offer the privilege to their Indian staff include HSBC and Eli Lilly.
    MY TAKE ON THIS:-

    My Vote: ‘FOR’ granting paternity leaves to male employees

    1. Entitlement to employees only up to 2 children by private sector companies
    2. Paid Paternity Leave of 10 working days at the minimum be granted immediately on child birth (100% pay)
    3. Entitlement to reduce working time by 25 percent during the first month immediately after availing 10 days of paid leave benefit
    4. Paternity leave of 15 days be granted during the first 3 months at half pay (50% pay)
    WHAT ARE YOUR VIEWS ON THIS???


    - VAISHALI PARGAONKAR



    Sources:
    BBC News Europe, 20 October 2010
    Women's Law Project Blog, June 24, 2010
    DNA, Sunday, Oct 23, 2005
    DNA, Monday, Feb 1, 2010
    Mint, Thu, Nov 11 2010
    Deccan Chronicle, February 26th, 2009
    Wikipedia

    Ratings and Recommendations by outbrain